As Supreme Court justices meet Friday to consider hearing the Wyoming corner-crossing case, attorneys for ranch owner Fred Eshelman are citing reasons that others have successfully employed to get their cases accepted for review.

The Supreme Court should accept Eshelmanโ€™s petition and hear the case because, his attorneys say, the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals’ decision on corner crossing โ€œcontravenesโ€ Supreme Court precedent. The case also has โ€œprofound legal and practical importance,โ€ Eshelman argues.

Eshelman is appealing the 10th Circuit Courtโ€™s decision that he cannot block the public from corner crossing to reach public land surrounded by his Carbon County ranch. He sued four Missouri hunters who stepped from one piece of public property to another adjacent one where the two met at a checkerboard corner with two parcels of Eshelmanโ€™s Elk Mountain Ranch. The hunters did not touch the ranch ownerโ€™s land.

Eshelman, through his ranch-owning company Iron Bar Holdings, maintains the hunters trespassed when they passed through the airspace above his property, a violation of Wyoming law. In seeking a Supreme Court hearing, Eshelmanโ€™s attorneys use two of the most successful approaches, expert Dan Schweitzer wrote in a guide, that petitioners have employed to convince the court to hear their cases.

โ€œThis petition does not meet this Courtโ€™s criteria for granting review.โ€

Ryan Semerad

Eshelmanโ€™s petition, however, is not based on the first reason the court lists for taking up petitions for a writ of certiorari, or review. Thatโ€™s when there are conflicting decisions on the same matter between two of the 13 federal circuit courts of appeal.

Thatโ€™s fodder for the hunters who say they donโ€™t want the court to consider the case, but are willing to fight if it does.

โ€œThis petition does not meet this Courtโ€™s criteria for granting review,โ€ one of the huntersโ€™ attorneys, Ryan Semerad, wrote in a Supreme Court filing. โ€œIron Bar doesnโ€™t claim that the decision below implicates a circuit split.โ€

Because the 10th Circuit Court is the only one to address corner crossing, โ€œNo split exists,โ€ the hunters contend.

Only 5% of petitions succeed

The 10th Circuit agreed with the hunters that the 1885 Unlawful Inclosures Act prevents Eshelman from blocking corner crossers. Based on the 10th Circuitโ€™s decision in March, corner crossing to reach isolated tracts of federal public land is now legal in Wyoming, Colorado, Utah, New Mexico, Kansas and Oklahoma.

Corner crossing arises from the publicโ€™s desire to reach its own public land in the checkerboard area of Wyoming. The checkerboard pattern of alternating square mile ownership overlays Eshelmanโ€™s wildlife-rich, 20,000-acre-plus Elk Mountain Ranch.

By preventing corner-crossing, Eshelman, a hunter himself, reaps for himself the bounty of public property โ€” property owned by all Americans โ€” critics contend.

Obtaining a review of federal appeals court decisions is rare. In 2024, the Supreme Court agreed to hear 5.2% of 1,344 petitions (not counting petitions from indigent appellants, of which there are many), according to an analysis that Empirical SCOTUS writer Adam Feldman published on SCOTUSblog.

Eshelmanโ€™s attorneys explain their reasoning that the appeal should be among those rare cases the court considers. They are second- and third-tier reasons, according to Schweitzerโ€™s 2019 guide โ€” lower court decisions that โ€œdirectly conflict[s] with Supreme Court precedentโ€ and issues that are โ€œextremely important.โ€

Nine Supreme Court justices will focus their attention Friday on this checkerboard corner in Carbon County where four Missouri hunters corner crossed to hunt on public land on Elk Mountain. (James Hasscamp) Mountain Ranch. (James Hasskamp)

Iron Bar claims the 10th Circuit Court contravened the Supreme Courtโ€™s own 1979 decision known as Leo Sheep. (Leo is a rural Carbon County settlement; Leo Sheep was a company named after the place.) In that case, the court ruled that the government did not have an implied easement to build a road across a common checkerboard corner to reach a reservoir used for recreation.

But Leo Sheep doesnโ€™t apply to the Iron Bar case, the hunters, and the 10th Circuit, contend. Among other things, Leo Sheep dealt with a road constructed on private land, and there also was another way to reach the reservoir.

The 10th Circuitโ€™s decision, written by Judge Timothy Tymkovich and agreed to by two other appellate judges, said that โ€œthe Supreme Court can also reconsider the scope of Leo Sheep, as it applies to this case.โ€

Profoundly important

Attorneys who write successful petitions also argue that their issue is an important one and, as Schweitzer puts it, their pleadings therefore โ€œdive into the merits to a far greater degree.โ€ Schweitzer writes that decisions that impair government officials from doing their jobs or that create a devastating impact on an industry can qualify for review.

โ€œIf a 140-year-old fence statute can be read to extinguish [state trespass laws] then no realm of traditional state property law is secure,โ€ Eshelmanโ€™s attorneys wrote. The 10th Circuit, if its decision stands, creates โ€œuncertainty for millions of landowners, recreationalists, and law enforcement officials across millions of acres of land.โ€

Stockmen warn that โ€œunrestrained public access โ€ฆ can cause great stress to livestock,โ€ Eshelmanโ€™s filings state. Further, the 10th Circuitโ€™s โ€œsweepingโ€ decision affecting property rights across millions of acres is โ€œan important question of federal law,โ€ that the Supreme Court should address.

Hunters say Eshelman has done an about-face.

When resisting the hunters’ request to move the case from state to federal court, Eshelman and Iron Bar โ€œdenied that this case implicates โ€˜an important question of federal law,โ€™โ€ the hunters state. Instead, the ranch owner described any federal issues as โ€œnot substantial.โ€

Eshelman argued in Wyomingโ€™s civil court that the case concerned โ€œonly two sectionsโ€ of his property and that the controversy involved โ€œwell under $75,000,โ€ in value, a huntersโ€™ brief states. Eshelman argued unsuccessfully in 2022 that those limited impacts should allow the ranch owner to pursue his suit in the state court system and not the federal one.

The hunters, however, convinced a federal judge to move the case to the federal court system. โ€œOnly after losing [his effort to keep the case in Wyoming courts] did Iron Bar revise its estimated damages from the huntersโ€™ momentary incursions on its airspace upwards to $8 million,โ€ the hunters’ attorneys wrote in a brief to the Supreme Court. Now Eshelman contends the impact is โ€œbillions,โ€ they wrote.

Eshelman could benefit from amicus briefs filed to support his petition, SCOTUSblog’s analysis of the last eight years of petitions shows. The United Property Owners of Montana, the Wyoming Stock Growers Association, the Wyoming Wool Growers Association, the Claremont Instituteโ€™s Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence and Montana Stockgrowers Associationโ€™s amicus filings boost Eshelmanโ€™s chances of obtaining a writ because they indicate a โ€œnational stake.โ€

The huntersโ€™ attorneys, however, chose neither to enlist an โ€œeliteโ€ and practiced Supreme Court lawyer nor ask for briefs from groups that support their public-access case. Doing either could have signaled to the Supreme Court that the case is indeed nationally significant, contrary to the huntersโ€™ position that the 10th Circuit appropriately took care of all necessary business.

The Supreme Courtโ€™s hearing on Friday will be held behind closed doors. Within several days, the court is expected to publish a list of cases that it will accept for review.

Angus M. Thuermer Jr. is the natural resources reporter for WyoFile. He is a veteran Wyoming reporter and editor with more than 35 years experience in Wyoming. Contact him at angus@wyofile.com or (307)...

Join the Conversation

12 Comments

WyoFile's goal is to provide readers with information and ideas that foster constructive conversations about the issues and opportunities our communities face. One small piece of how we do that is by offering a space below each story for readers to share perspectives, experiences and insights. For this to work, we need your help.

What we're looking for: 

  • Your real name โ€” first and last. 
  • Direct responses to the article. Tell us how your experience relates to the story.
  • The truth. Share factual information that adds context to the reporting.
  • Thoughtful answers to questions raised by the reporting or other commenters.
  • Tips that could advance our reporting on the topic.
  • No more than three comments per story, including replies. 

What we block from our comments section, when we see it:

  • Pseudonyms. WyoFile stands behind everything we publish, and we expect commenters to do the same by using their real name.
  • Comments that are not directly relevant to the article. 
  • Demonstrably false claims, what-about-isms, references to debunked lines of rhetoric, professional political talking points or links to sites trafficking in misinformation.
  • Personal attacks, profanity, discriminatory language or threats.
  • Arguments with other commenters.

Other important things to know: 

  • Appearing in WyoFileโ€™s comments section is a privilege, not a right or entitlement. 
  • Weโ€™re a small team and our first priority is reporting. Depending on whatโ€™s going on, comments may be moderated 24 to 48 hours from when theyโ€™re submitted โ€” or even later. If you comment in the evening or on the weekend, please be patient. Weโ€™ll get to it when weโ€™re back in the office.
  • Weโ€™re not interested in managing squeaky wheels, and even if we wanted to, we don't have time to address every single commenterโ€™s grievance. 
  • Try as we might, we will make mistakes. Weโ€™ll fail to catch aliases, mistakenly allow folks to exceed the comment limit and occasionally miss false statements. If thatโ€™s going to upset you, itโ€™s probably best to just stick with our journalism and avoid the comments section.
  • We donโ€™t mediate disputes between commenters. If you have concerns about another commenter, please donโ€™t bring them to us.

The bottom line:

If you repeatedly push the boundaries, make unreasonable demands, get caught lying or generally cause trouble, we will stop approving your comments โ€” maybe forever. Such moderation decisions are not negotiable or subject to explanation. If civil and constructive conversation is not your goal, then our comments section is not for you. 

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. I have not heard anything about whether this Administration has weighed in on this issue. I would hate to bet that this Supreme Court will go against almost anything this Administration wants.

  2. Eshelman’s (and no Mr. Sir, Dr. Master, etc.) goal is to illegally possess public land, period. He may of owned the Wyoming Game and Fish, the Carbon County Sheriff and the crooked banana republic Carbon County Attorney’s Office, but he didn’t owned for good ole’ Missouri boys that all they wanted to do was access and hunt public land. The only positive is that Eshelman single handily with his manipulation of our state and county agencies and stupid criminal charges and civil lawsuits was to put corner crossing as a LEGAL maneuver in the law books. There’s only one more big laugh coming and that’s from SCOTUS

  3. Mr. Thuermer has done an outstsanding job of laying out the issues here. It reinforces my understanding of the hunters’ / public’s right to access public land. I appreciate seeing the legal “issues” so clearly laid out. Especially notable is the switch in argument made by Mr. Eshelman, from the case not being relevant to federal law to being important in federal law. I’m betting the Supremes won’t hear it.

  4. We will see if money and power trumps in this case. Though they were knowing buyers, as one judge said, they have enclosed public lands and excluded other uses as prohibited by the Unlawful Inclosures Act. A body of law has been passed to try and nullify that Act.

  5. One inaccuracy of the Eshelman suit, as reported here, is that according to Wyoming law passed in 2023, the airspace being invaded above private property only applies to drone activity, not in general to anyone on foot that is trying to get from one square to another. That leaves me wondering if that is noted in the lawsuit. From what Iโ€™ve read in previous articles about this ongoing story I did not see that the hunters used drones, only apps on their phones. At any rate, I hope these this group of junior lawyers decide not to recommend to SCOTUS to look at this frivolous suit. But as Iโ€™ve said before, put a bunch of lawyers on a thing and it really gets screwed up. Frankly, I donโ€™t believe Eshelman deserves much respect for the trouble heโ€™s caused these hunters over such a frivolous complaint.

  6. If Iron Bar Ranch isn’t going to allow the corner crossing then they shouldn’t be allowed to use federal land either.

  7. So if Eschelman wins then I can sue anyone who walks down the sidewalk adjacent to my property and waves his/her hand over my property. Trespassing. I’ll get those little second graders waving their hands as they pass by my house. Send ’em to detention camps. Trespassing!

  8. not once in your article did you reference doctor Eshleman by his title ?

    or give mr.Eshleman the respect of a mr. in front of his surname ?

    kind of low ball journalism !

    1. Stating the name Eshelman will do just fine, Paul. There are a lot of adjectives that could be used in a _________ Eshelman, but I’m sure Wyofile would not want to print them. After the Supreme Courts laughs off Eshelman’s petition, he might as well pack up and leave Wyoming

      1. Seriously, what a ridiculous comment. Eshelman has kinda brought this situation on himself, how he is addressed is beside the point. He has proven to be one of the most petty wealthy landowners in this state (and there are WAY too many). I can think of plenty of adjectives that better describe him besides just Eshleman, but we can’t post that. I certainly hope SCrOTUS does the right thing for a change and throws this out.

    2. Paul, I don’t see anyone else referenced by “Mr,” “Mrs,” “Ms,” or “Miss” in Wyofile articles, or in any news article by any other source for that matter. It’s standard practice to identify persons initially by their first and last names, and after that by last name only. Why should this individual be treated differently? Because he’s rich?

      1. Most forget that in Leo sheep’s case, the supreme Court did remind us that the government could take the land for the vested interest of the public. Also that the government wanted to pay for the easement, which has been the common method forever, and Leo sheep refused. With that case, the supreme court overstepped it’s bounds. That has been what made all the mess in the first place. The current supreme court should address this and rectify the wrongful Leo sheep decision. No one ever said that rich people are the smartest people in the room, but most people would agree that rich people tend to try and find someone who will fight for their cause, regardless of whether it is right or wrong.