Wyoming’s first citizens initiative to land on the ballot in 30 years has stirred up a contentious fight, pitting property tax relief against local government funding for essential services.
Proposition 1, also known as The People’s Initiative to Limit Property Tax in Wyoming through a Homeowner’s Property Exemption, landed on the Nov. 3 general election ballot with the backing of more than 30,000 valid signatures collected around the state. If passed, it will exempt 50% of a primary residence’s assessed value from property taxation, causing Wyoming’s annual property tax revenues to decrease by an estimated $92.6 million to $124.8 million.
The initiative was among a raft of efforts to relieve property owners after COVID-era real estate trends inflated residential values and associated taxes. Some of those efforts have already borne fruit, including a 2025 bill to create a 25% exemption on the first $1 million of a primary residence’s fair market value.
That measure shrank 2025 revenue pools for public education, municipalities and special districts such as hospitals. Some county governments implemented hiring freezes and mandated departmental budget cuts. Other entities closed libraries and stopped maintaining parks. Many dipped into reserves.
These impacts have been cast as cautionary tales — examples of painful consequences brought on by tax cuts. Over the last year, a chorus of opposition has swelled against Proposition 1 — voices that include county treasurers, fire chiefs, education advocates and perhaps most notably, prominent Republicans. If Proposition 1 passes, they say, the damages will spiral out of control.
“The reduction by 50% would have an immediate and devastating effect on the services most Wyoming citizens rely upon in their communities,” Gov. Mark Gordon wrote in an op-ed opposing Proposition 1. Calling it “tax reform” is inaccurate, he wrote. “Tax reform is fundamentally different from destroying a tax base or relying on the legislature to fund essential services.”

Proposition 1’s supporters, including many who align with the far-right Wyoming Freedom Caucus, say misinformation capitalizing on fear has blown the impact of the tax reduction out of proportion.
Opponents are leaving out important nuances such as the fact that the residential property tax cut won’t apply to property tax categories like mineral, industrial, agricultural and commercial, former state representative and Proposition 1 advocate Marti Halverson said. As for the predictions of hardships, she said, they don’t ring true.
“When you look at all the revenues that have been hoarded by counties and special districts and cities and towns all over the state since 2019, I am not buying it that anyone has cut anything to the bone,” she said.
Heightened rhetoric on both sides of the issue has many voters curious about where the truth lies and what’s at stake. Tax systems are complicated, and factors like assessment fluctuations and owner opt-in rates make it impossible to pin down Proposition 1’s exact implications.
That said, understanding the context around both sides’ arguments can help voters decide whether to vote yes or no. Here are three things to know about Proposition 1 before you go to the polls.
Tax bills spiked, then came reform efforts.
Wyoming residents have a relatively low tax burden and no income tax, due largely to the state’s reliance on severance taxes on mineral extraction.
Homeowners do pay residential property taxes. Those residential taxes are pooled with property taxes from minerals, industrial sites, agricultural land and more, and the generated revenues help fund K-12 public schools, county government, special districts, community colleges, along with cities and towns.
During the COVID pandemic, so-called “Zoomers” — newly untethered from their offices — flooded into the Mountain West, snapping up homes, creating more demand and fueling home price increases. That resulted in spiking tax bills for some Wyoming homeowners; increases varied by county. In Park County, the average homeowner saw their tax bills jump over 60% in three years.
The sticker shock that ensued helped trigger a wide-ranging relief effort. In October of 2023, two-time gubernatorial candidate Brent Bien, along with his former campaign manager Rich Weber and former Wyoming Republican Party state committeewoman Cheryl Aguiar, secured approval to begin collecting signatures to get a 50% exemption on the ballot, with no cap on the value.

Bien did not respond to WyoFile’s request for an interview, but in a recent conversation with The Talk Shop radio host Eric Henderson, Weber said the measure intends to protect homeowners on fixed incomes who cannot afford ever-mounting tax bills. Weber likened claims of service cuts and closures to “crying wolf,” calling those warnings “phony baloney.”
Secretary of State Chuck Gray certified the initiative in January 2025 after verifying more than 30,000 signatures. More than 50% of voters will need to vote yes for it to pass.
The numbers indicate high interest — at least when the signature collecting was happening between late 2023 and early 2025. Wyoming lawmakers also passed several property tax relief measures after signature collecting began, including a 25% homeowner exemption and a 50% long-term homeowner exemption.
The latter efforts have already achieved property tax relief, Proposition 1 opponents argue. Further cuts Proposition 1 would impose, they say, are reckless. In his op-ed, Gordon likened it to cutting “the legs out from under communities and counties.”
County and special district officials are scared. Proponents say this is a ‘chicken little’ tactic.
Residential property tax collections dropped from $656 million in 2024 to $535 million in 2025, according to the Wyoming Taxpayers Association.
That amounted to smaller revenues for county administrators, hospital districts and others. Cities reduced park maintenance, libraries closed, agencies charged more for subsidized childcare, smaller crews reduced weed spraying and department heads implemented hiring freezes.
In Fremont County, administrators cut $2.5 million from the budget, which entailed trimming costs for courthouse security, increasing fees and slashing the library budget — an action that angered many locals.
During fraught budget discussions, county officials warned that Proposition 1 would only exacerbate the situation and lead to outcomes like library branch closures. If it passes, Commission Chair Larry Allen said in a meeting, “we’re looking at over a third of our budget just disappearing.”
That became a common refrain among county treasurers, fire chiefs and education advocates. Consequences, they warned, will include fire station closures, less manpower for emergency responses and smaller budgets for road and bridge infrastructure, community colleges and public schools.
“If Prop 1 passes, nearly every county in Wyoming, except mineral-rich counties and counties with wealthy homeowners, will face serious reductions in funding for police, fire, EMS, hospitals, and road and sewer infrastructure,” according to the Wyoming Taxpayers Association.
This kind of rhetoric does not sway proponents like Halverson, who argue that county officials are capable of finding responsible cuts without having to axe critical services and that both state and local governments have flush reserves.
“The sky is not falling,” she said.
Wyoming’s 23 counties vary in their reserve amounts; mineral-rich counties generally have healthier savings. The state, meanwhile, has a robust “rainy day fund” of more than $1 billion, but its function is not to backfill local tax shortfalls, opponents say.
Anti-Proposition 1 messaging has ignored the measure’s nuances, Halverson said, such as the fact that homeowners would have to opt in to get the exemption, they must prove primary-residence status and that it only applies to the residential property structure, not the land it sits on.
In a video posted to the Wyoming Freedom Caucus Facebook page, Wheatland Republican Rep. Jeremy Haroldson clarified many of those facts.
“Prop 1 is simply a targeted property tax exemption for qualified homeowners, not a 50% government cut,” Haroldson said.
The opposition movement has grown and includes many Republicans.
The Wyoming Education Association, Wyoming Hospital Association, Wyoming Association of Community College Trustees, Wyoming Realtors and Wyoming Taxpayers Association all oppose Proposition 1, creating a formidable alliance.
The measure “is not justified and not fiscally prudent,” the taxpayers association wrote in an op-ed, and it stands to hobble counties by slashing revenue with no plan to replace the losses.
The “Vote No on Prop 1” PAC is well-resourced. Campaign finance filings show nearly $2 million in contributions; the National Education Association has donated $1.4 million. Bien, Weber and Aguiar’s PAC, BCR Voter Initiatives, meanwhile, reported contributions of less than $4,000.
The Wyoming Republican Party endorsed Proposition 1. But prominent Republicans have joined the opposition. Long-serving lawmakers like Sen. Ogden Driskill, R-Devils Tower, and Rep. Lloyd Larsen, R-Lander, signed an op-ed against it. Gubernatorial candidate Eric Barlow and Steve Harshman, who is running for Superintendent of Public Instruction, also expressed opposition.
In this way, Proposition 1 has become another arena in the Wyoming Republican Party’s fracture, with the Freedom Caucus bloc splintering from more moderately conservative Republicans.

After years of consolidating power in Wyoming’s Legislature, the Freedom Caucus in August lost majority control of the House and backslid in the Senate, which many say indicates a backlash.
In a newsletter that elaborated on her reasons for opposing Proposition 1, Rep. Liz Storer, D-Jackson, posited that the tax measure is “the last relic of a failed agenda.
“The Freedom Caucus used the COVID-era spike in home values to push for slashing property taxes,” wrote Storer, a member of the Legislature’s Revenue Committee. “In August, Republican voters rejected these extremists. Proposition One belongs on the trash heap with the rest of that agenda.”
(Storer is the president and CEO of the George B. Storer Foundation, a financial supporter of WyoFile. The foundation has no role in WyoFile’s editorial content.)

I live in a house I built with my own hands. Paid it off. Now I’m retired. It infuriates me to see Government doing everything they can to force me out of my home. They’d be more than happy to force me to sell out to some wealthy newcomer who has more to take. We need to get rid of property taxes on primary residences completely. Tax everybody if you need money, not just property owners. Rob someone else.
If we had not been watching lavish spending by our local government entities, tax payers would likely be more swayed by the sky is falling propaganda surrounding Proposition 1. In Converse County, we watched our commissioners build a “Taj Mahal” justice center after it was voted down twice. Shortly after the second time it was voted down, likely because of the exorbitant price tag, I attended a conference where law enforcement personnel from other states were in attendance. A dispatcher from Minnesota was bragging about their new justice center, with all the amenities and more beds than the one proposed for Converse County. She showed pictures of a simple practical building complex, and quoted a cost a little more than half of our proposed cost. I wondered then Why we couldn’t build one at that cost. Once built, I understood. It was a lavish building, all glass and peaks and wasted space. Now we also pay more to maintain the lavish structure that has to cost more than a simple, practical structure. Now we have a “community center” being built that we didn’t vote on, and yes they are talking cutting the budget for necessary services because they have to staff and maintain it. The more money government entities get, the more they spend, until tax payers say stop. The first cuts threatened, of course, are essential services, not the excess.
Property taxes are just one example of the problem. No one wants to defund city and county services, but the era of giving politicians and public servants a “blank check” is over. I can count easily on both hands people I know who are upset with the city about council votes and recent developments. It’s time to put line items on the ballot, and not giveaways to city officials who will easily make decisions that negatively impact your or my neighborhood while protecting their part of town.
Fund the libraries? Sure. Dump unwanted commercial activities (rail ties anyone?), or vehicle abuses in my neighborhood? NO. Vote to make them accountable. They won’t do it on their own.
What were property taxes in 2019? Would passing Proposition 1 reduce tax revenues to what they were in 2019? 2021?…
What happened to the windfall Wyoming counties must have collected since 2020 as a result of property appreciation? Was it all spent as the pie chart seems to suggest? If not, where is it?
If this is not tax reform, what suggestions do the opponents of Proposition 1 have for tax reform? Expanding Medicaid so hospitals don’t have to treat as many people without getting paid? Requiring employers who employ over a certain number of people to provide health insurance for their employees? Separating property and commercial tax rates? Commercial property values appreciate at different rates than residential property rates. There should be a way to adjust for that. Perhaps those millions of PAC dollars could be better spent. If a tax system is broken people are going to rebel against it.
We’re in the midst of a moderate tax revolt. We’ll see what percentage of voters back Prop1 to get a feel of its size. Thankfully, the legislature and governor already passed seven bills into law, while also changing our State constitution to provide a level of tax relief. Whether Prop1 passes or not, some form of backfill needs to be provided to maintain the long term health of our local entities. Rather than leaning in towards some other tax to provide the backfill, sales/use or income taxes that’ll just pick a different tax payer pocket, the new legislature should consider providing backfill from the massive minerals trust investment returns flooding our State general fund. These returns are not someone else’s taxes, they’re investment returns averaging $350M for several years, but have recently sprung to a record breaking $800M given bond yields recovery from the crazy low-yield covid days. Given market forces, it looks like this trend higher will continue. The strategy is to have the tax payers ‘profit-share’ with the State. Good years with large returns, the State provides 100% backfill. Lean years, the State can share the backfill load between reducing the homeowners tax exemptions and funds pulled from investment returns. I’m convinced we can make all this work in such a way that everyone wins. The tax payer gets meaningful tax cuts. The local entities remain whole. The State modulates backfill dependent on returns. And the tax revolt is soothed. Let’s end the zero-sum ‘I win – you lose’ game we’re stuck in currently.
Excellent piece. As a militant, no-party-preference moderate who serves on the board of a county taxpayer group in another state, I believe I would vote “No.” Prop 1 seems to be overkill.
People move here because of low taxes. If the Zoomers would go back home, the problem would be solved.
One best be careful of what they wish for. They might just get it. Look forward to consider what new taxes could come into play when services decrease
Something that I have yet to see addressed is how current property taxes revenues paid on private homes compares to the same taxes pre-Covid, and what those same revenues would be if Prop 1 is implemented. Throughout the furor over raising home property taxes we have been told that it is the result of raising home values, which, as the story goes, are largely the result of an influx of people moving to Wyoming, many to escape Covid restrictions in other parts of the country.
Regardless of the cause of the recent surge in home values and the corresponding increase in tax collections, the entities that ultimately receive those taxes must have seen a substantial increase in their income as home prices rose. Unless that increase was added to savings, it must have been used to increase services. Where I’m going with this is would Prop 1 really force the recipients of those tax revenues to cut services to the bone, or merely to reduce their spending to a level that existed before home prices took a dramatic upward turn?
I believe this is very germane to the Prop 1 question, and I would love for supporters and opponents of the issue address the question.
I have often heard the refrain from the hard right that if you don’t love our country then leave. The same can be applied here. If you feel you are so heavily burdened by taxes in Jackson or WY, then perhaps it is time to leave and find another place in our country with lower taxes.
The wealthiest will continue to get richer because of this tax cut and since so many do not live here full time(6 months and 1 day) they don’t care about schools,roads,the hospital etc. Those in the middle or lower class will be hit the hardest. Libraries,schools, hospitals,Fire services,EMS,Weed and Pest are just a few of the services everyone expects to be at the top of their game. The state has not shown any appetite for backfilling deficits in spite of what some say about education being a constitutional right in WY.
Why is no appreciation or understanding given to the reasons people want to live here? Yes it is beautiful. But it is our community that takes care of all parts of your quality of life that makes it so appealing.
As with so many of the Freedom caucus “policies”, it is clear that cruelty towards the poor is at the top of the list. Their name is the opposite of who they are.
It’s amazing to see the number of people that have bought into the theft of private property. That’s exactly what property taxes are. People on limited income cannot afford the insane rates that occur in some areas. Why should they have to “leave” just because taxes keep going up? If you want better schools, pay for them. Why should someone 80 years old have to pay them? Raise the taxes on second homes if you want but a homestead should never have a tax on it just so the homeowner can keep it. Stop wasting money and budget better and you (govt) can still afford to pay for the services without undue burden on a primary (homesteaded) homeowner. Nobody can afford to live in Jackson except the extremely wealthy. How many people that work there can afford to actually live there? NONE! They all drive there from other areas.
And those extremely wealthy individuals you mentioned are exactly who would benefit the most from this tax cut. 50% off of a multimillion dollar estate is considerably more than I’m going to realize on my double wide. While county services designed to provide help to rural homesteaders, like conservation offices, and outreach programs, would evaporate. So the rich get richer on the backs of the working class that you describe. Who, by the way, probably commute from Idaho, and wouldn’t realize any tax relief from this initiative at all.
IIRC, the 50%only applies to the 1st $1M of a homes value.
It’s important to keep in mind it was rising property values and the relative tax that forced retirees on fixed incomes to lose their homes in other States. It can happen, I say let the retirees keep their homes.
Do you mean to say, “ multi billion dollar estate”
I’ve lived here for fifty years. Built my own house and paid it off. Now YOU are telling ME to leave? Not happening. There should be no property tax on a family’s primary residence.
Rob someone else.