Thousands turned out to hear former President Donald Trump and other far-right politicians speak in Casper May 28, 2022. (Mike Koshmrl/WyoFile)

It was difficult to know who was more irritated, me or the Walmart checker.  I was pissed because she was moving slow. She was pissed because the election was stolen. Too squeamish to listen closely, too fascinated to ignore, I half-listened to her conversation with the customer ahead of me as the checker moved items (sloth like) across the scanner. In short order, they volleyed the words “fraud,” “sham” and “rigged” while simultaneously clucking their tongues and praying for our country. 


The ladies’ MAGA haiku parroted at countless candidate forums this summer (all of it baseless and self-serving) neatly summed up everything wrong in my Republican Party. Though we likely share many conservative values, this far-right view is not representative of the values held by so many of us in the GOP, and the continued perpetuation of rigged election and fear mongering has been nothing but destructive, both for the party and our state.   

Yet, despite indications across the country that the former president is losing his grip on the Republican Party, “MAGA forever!” remains a winning strategy here in Wyoming where both chambers of the Legislature push further right each election cycle.

Almost half of the Wyoming House members are new. At least one-third of them align with the most rigid arm of the Republican Party, the Freedom Caucus, whose runny definition of “freedom” pinballs between whimsical and reactionary. 

Still, love is strong for those candidates who perpetuated MAGA falsehoods on the campaign trail. It should be the shame of the state that Natrona County Republican voters elected candidate Bob Ide, who was on the grounds of the Capitol on Jan. 6th, into the State Senate.  

There’s a disconnect here. Gov. Gordon, who has deftly maneuvered the line between party extremists and party moderates, was recently named America’s most popular governor. The people love him. The hardliners who control his own state party do not.   

At a recent GOP event in Converse County, for example, most of the public officials in the room received polite applause upon introduction, according to a friend of mine who was there. Secretary of State Chuck Gray, however, received a standing ovation. Gray’s campaign was heavy on misinformation, hosting statewide free movie nights of the MAGA porn show “2000 Mules,” which alleges a vast conspiracy by unnamed left-wing groups to steal the 2020 election. Since its release, law enforcement officials and fact-checkers have thoroughly discredited the film’s allegations. The filmmakers have declined to provide evidence for their central claims, likely because there is no credible evidence to support this dark fairy tale.

Yet Gray handily defeated Sen. Tara Nethercott, an experienced and accomplished Republican lawmaker who demonstrated a deep knowledge of the secretary of state’s office and its function, but an unwillingness to embrace election lies. The irony, of course, is that the folks who ran on the premise of a rigged election system were the successful products of that very system. What will that look like when they have the keys to the secretary of state’s office?

Don’t panic. Nothing is in control. Alt-right lawmakers will likely continue pandering to an electorate snuggled in their vacuum of disinformation. They’ll thumb their noses at decorum and thump their chests at their very meanness. They view it as a badge of honor. I view it as a disgrace. Such preening is a grave disservice to our state and the net effect is a paralyzed legislative body. Nobody wins.

Lawmaking is serious business. The federal government owns almost half the land in Wyoming. Our state budget is a complex web of funding streams and — like it or not — a significant portion comes from the federal government. We rely on federal revenues to fund health care, social services, highways, housing, clean water, critical infrastructure and innumerable other government functions. This past year, several rural hospitals discontinued offering obstetric care for expectant mothers. Rather than ignoring these facts in favor of simply bashing the federal government for political expediency, lawmakers need to focus on providing solutions instead of winning Patriot of the Day in the Legislature.

Seasoned lawmakers will tell you the job is much trickier, more nuanced than they ever imagined prior to holding their seat. Issues facing our state simply cannot be solved through lazy loyalty no-votes. There’s plenty of present and former conservatives who have skillfully threaded the needle between necessary legislation to keep our economy pumping and limiting government. I hope the extremists get that.

This is my party too. Will this blood-red arm of the Legislature represent all conservative voices? When faced with the meaty reality of lawmaking, who among the outer banks of the party will be courageous enough to walk back the rhetoric and put public service ahead of their political ambitions? I encourage our lawmakers to fight the temptation to burn precious session time grandstanding on who should use what bathroom and instead focus on the boring business of state government.

The extremists’ currency is fear. My Walmart checker friend nailed it. She’s scared for our country. Dangerous times. Though she can’t articulate her concerns with cogent authority, she just knows she’s afraid. Far simpler to limit those conversations to the checkout line. We’ll expect more from our lawmakers, notwithstanding their hue of red, to ignore the bogeyman and focus on the mundane.

Susan Stubson is a lifelong Republican and is on the executive committee of the Natrona County Republican Party. She has written extensively on state politics, cultural resources and outdoor recreation....

Join the Conversation


Want to join the discussion? Fantastic, here are the ground rules: * Provide your full name — no pseudonyms. WyoFile stands behind everything we publish and expects commenters to do the same. * No personal attacks, profanity, discriminatory language or threats. Keep it clean, civil and on topic. *WyoFile does not fact check every comment but, when noticed, submissions containing clear misinformation, demonstrably false statements of fact or links to sites trafficking in such will not be posted. *Individual commenters are limited to three comments per story, including replies.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Ms. Benson: You forgot one. Conservative QOPers’ currency is a veritable trifecta of treason, hatred, and greed. Another hat trick.

  2. This is a time for close observation of the activity during the session when governing for all should happen. Good reporting of their activities and the results is critical for all. Close scrutiny is imperative.

  3. You lay down with dogs, you’ll get fleas

    Reasonable repubs have to take the brunt of blame for our current political circus. For years, they’ve sat idly while the scripture spouting, fantasy believing, non-rational Q patriots spread lies and conspiracy theories. Where were the “reasonable” repubs while that was going on? Why wasn’t there a bigger pushback on the stupidity that was being said?

    “Reasonable” repubs knew they was no fraud on the scale that the fringe wanted there to be. “Reasonable” repubs didn’t speak against the lies. “Reasonable” repubs allowed chrump to do whatever he wanted with no repercussions. “Reasonable” repubs turned a blind eye to the traitors who participated in the insurrection.

    Now the “reasonable” repubs are sounding the alarm because they can’t control the mental ward of their party. You reap what you sow.

    Forgive me if I have no sympathy for the people and careers that have been affected by the ignorance and inaction of the republican whack jobs.

  4. Carl Hulse put it most succinctly: The far right’s agenda is “defund, disrupt and dismantle government, not to participate in it.”