(Flickr Creative Commons/Alex E. Proimos)

Here in Wyoming and across the country, people enrolled in Medicare are engaged in the annual task of assessing their supplemental insurance coverage. Insurance companies anxious to acquire more customers have flooded my mail box with pitches urging me to sign up before the open enrollment period ends Dec. 7.


The supplemental plans, known as Medigap, are offered by private insurers to cover some or all of the out-of-pocket costs that Medicare Parts A and B do not. Medicare’s website enables its clients to compare the “Medigap” plans easily, but it’s still not an easy decision. It requires gambling on one’s health — or in more official language, risk assessment. As elderly humans, we senior citizens know that cancer, a Parkinson’s diagnosis, or onset of diabetes can suddenly change a person’s health needs and send medical costs skyrocketing. Will it happen this year? Next? 

Wyoming Senior Citizens, a private, nonprofit organization, provides a buyer’s guide put together by the Wyoming Department of Insurance. The guide provides a sense of an insurer’s ability to meet its obligations to policyholders via ratings from A.M. Best.

Even with those resources, it’s important for seniors and their families to be vigilant for deceptive advertising and offers. Watch for products that promise a range of services for “free” or “at no additional cost.” 

In the past I’ve relied on the AARP to fight back against scammers on behalf of seniors, but my trust waned when I realized the organization benefits from some of the deception. 

Which brings me to UnitedHealthcare. This giant insurance provider based in Minnesota first contacted me in late October. It advertises regularly in publications I receive from the AARP, the great advocate for senior citizens and defender of both Medicare and Social Security.

UnitedHealthcare assured me that its “AARP Medicare Advantage Choice Plan 1” provides more benefits than original Medicare. The sales pitch got my attention, but not for the reasons the company hoped. I have followed reporting on the use of advantage plans to boost insurance company profits through practices that the federal government considers “potentially fraudulent.”

So why does AARP, which regularly urges Medicare and Social Security recipients to be on the lookout for fraud and scams, continue its business relationship with UnitedHealthcare? 

A June 5, 2022 Washington Post report detailed Advantage Plan manipulation by big insurance companies. The newspaper relied upon a report from the Office of the Inspector General and interviews with doctors and other providers. The Post noted that MedPAC, a government watchdog panel, found Medicare Advantage plans increasingly cost taxpayers more money to run than traditional fee-for service Medicare.

“The higher cost, what MedPAC labels ‘excess payments,’ reached $12 billion in 2020 out of total program costs of $350 billion and are projected to top $16 billion next year, MedPAC said in March,” the Post reported.

How did they do this? Insurers pressured doctors to add more “risk adjustment codes” to a patient’s file, even if those codes referred to long-resolved health issues. “If companies add more risk adjustment codes to a Medicare Advantage beneficiary’s medical record to receive higher payment — but don’t spend money on the additional care — they make more money.”

Your friend who recovered from breast cancer 15 years ago but is no longer treated for cancer illustrates how this data mining works. The insurers find these old health issues, then include them as part of the risk they incur even though the patient no longer requires treatment.

The industry says it follows Medicare’s rules and its sometimes-vague regulations and ensures their plans can anticipate health problems and reduce hospitalizations.

Nevertheless, the government, according to the Post, “considers it improper — potentially even fraudulent — for providers to add codes for medical conditions that have been resolved or have no bearing on a patient’s current health.”

The Office of Inspector General noted that UnitedHealthcare “stood out among Medicare Advantage companies for its aggressive use of risk assessments without evidence new risk codes were related to ongoing medical care,” the Post wrote. 

I contacted the Wyoming AARP office in Cheyenne to determine where AARP stands on these UnitedHealthcare practices. I wanted to find out if AARP will continue to take royalties from UnitedHealthcare and sell advertising that touts the company to its millions of members.

The Wyoming office advised me to contact the national office. I spoke with AARP’s External Relations Director Colby Nelson, who assured me AARP works hard for seniors and does so with great transparency. He pointed to recently passed legislation that enables Medicare to negotiate drug prices as one of AARP’s great lobbying successes.

But he dodged the moral question I asked: Given its reputation as a defender of Medicare and Social Security against fraud and scams, should AARP continue to accept royalties and advertising dollars from a company whose Medicare Advantage plan management has raised such significant questions from doctors, the press, and the government itself?

Nelson wouldn’t comment on a potential investigation like the one involving UnitedHealthCare, but said in an email AARP expects all companies it works with to meet legal, ethical, and quality standards and monitors their performance.

AARP licenses its intellectual property to a variety of companies that provide commercial benefits to its members. “These provider companies are vetted, and the royalty revenue generated” — more than $1 billion according to AARP’s most recent audit — “is used by AARP in support of our mission to empower people to live as they choose when they get older,” Nelson wrote.

The front page of AARP’s November “Bulletin” features a headline that says “Fraud Surge — Medicare Hit by New Scam Types.” The story frets over a recent OIG study that detected “potentially fraudulent” billing by health providers of roughly $128 million due to “new channels of Medicare fraud opened during the COVID pandemic …”

I agree we should be concerned about these recent problems, but that sum falls far, far below the $12 billion in “excess payments” made to Medicare Advantage insurers that were questioned by MedPAC.

In that same issue of the AARP Bulletin there’s a Fraud Watch column warning seniors that scammers will “seduce you.” The AARP should consider its own advice and reassess its relationship with UnitedHealthcare.

Dan Neal is the former executive director of the Equality State Policy Center. He worked for decades as a journalist in Wyoming, including as the special legislative editor for WyoFile.

Join the Conversation


Want to join the discussion? Fantastic, here are the ground rules: * Provide your full name — no pseudonyms. WyoFile stands behind everything we publish and expects commenters to do the same. * No personal attacks, profanity, discriminatory language or threats. Keep it clean, civil and on topic. *WyoFile does not fact check every comment but, when noticed, submissions containing clear misinformation, demonstrably false statements of fact or links to sites trafficking in such will not be posted. *Individual commenters are limited to three comments per story, including replies.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. ….Medicare Advantage is a “ROYAL SCAM”. It’s NOT MEDICARE, it’s private insurance which was started by the George Bush admin.. It now comprises over half of Medicare qualified folks. They get you involved at 62 when you don’t have a lot of med issues. The ‘dentistry and vision’ are mostly just exam fees and ‘every’ procedure needs to be OKed with the insurer. Medicare and your MediGap plan (B 20%) need not be Oked, they just pay it. Some Medical agencies have actually changed clients from trad MediCare to MediCare Advantage programs without telling their clients about it. If you’ve had MA for years and want to get back on trad MediCare, you will have to make up the cost of Part B from when you started or switched to MA. DON’T DO IT, it’s a scam from Big Pharma and those folks are CRIMINALS!!!….

  2. For assistance detecting and/or reporting potential Medicare fraud, abuse, or errors, call the Wyoming Senior Medicare Patrol (SMP) at 1 (800) 856-4398. Some common examples of suspected Medicare fraud or abuse are:
    You signed up for a plan after being told by a company that certain prescriptions or services were covered, but after reviewing your EOB, you found they were not covered by the plan and you received a bill instead
    Billing for services or supplies that were not provided
    Providing unsolicited supplies to beneficiaries
    Misrepresenting a diagnosis, patient identity, or other facts to justify payment
    Prescribing or providing excessive or unnecessary tests and services
    Offering or receiving a kickback (bribe) in exchange for a Medicare number
    Violating the participating provider agreement with Medicare by refusing to bill Medicare for covered services or items and billing the beneficiary instead

    Residents of other states will find their SMP here: https://www.smpresource.org

  3. Thanks Mr. Neal every citizenin our state should read your article. The fear induced financial damage to Wyoming Seniors continues.

    1. Agree with you Terry it is a minefield with selecting a Medicare insurance plan.
      Dan Neal thank you for your in-depth report. I would like to see a report on the pit falls of being admitted to the hospital vs being put under observation in the hospital. Another insurance nightmare seniors face and any education you can provide would be welcomed.
      Thank you again